Site Information

  • Coney Island Hot Dog Mix

Coney Island Hot Dog Mix from Fort Wayne

Usually Ships within 24 hours
Condition: New In Stock

Product Description

Enjoy a slightly different version of the Coney dog by using our Fort Wayne Style Coney Island Hot Dog Mix. We’ve got a ballpark delicious recipe to make the perfect dog. Add cheddar cheese powder, onions, ground mustard seed, and ketchup or just go plain with our special sauce to give you that unforgettable Coney flavor. This is our own special mix of spices, cumin, chili pepper, paprika, dehydrated onion, brown sugar, garlic, black pepper, celery and salt. It’s simple, fun, and sure to be a hit at your next cookout, party, or family night dinner.


Here’s our Coney Island hot dog mix recipe:

  1. Brown 1 lb. hamburger (high-fat content [70/30] for original Coney flavor) with 1/3 cup onions.
  2. Stir together ¼ cup of our Mix with 1/2 cup water.
  3. Simmer 30 – 45 minutes while stirring to make sure the sauce does not burn.
  4. Serve with hotdogs, and don't forget to steam the buns!


Spices, (come on, it's a secret) Cumin, Chili Pepper, Paprika, Dehydrated Onion, Brown Sugar, Garlic, Black Pepper, Celery, Salt

Find Similar Products by Category

Product Reviews

Write Review

  1. Great Memories

    Posted by Unknown on 22nd Jun 2018

    Love the taste. Now I have a recipe for the sauce. The spice works great in other foods too.

  2. Not Even Close

    Posted by K on 1st Aug 2017

    Was excited but..... huge disappointment.
    It pains me to say that because I was hoping....

  3. Not there yet!

    Posted by Unknown on 24th Feb 2017

    I live 30 miles from the Coney Island that they are supposedly selling this as, this may have a slight hint of the flavor or maybe not as it does not taste like the Ft Wayne store coney sauce at all not that it isn't good just not what they claim it as.

  4. Coney Dog Seasoning

    Posted by Unknown on 28th Sep 2016

    I have looks for years for a coney seasoning that made authenic tasting coneys at home. This seasoning is the one. I make large batches (20 to 30 dogs) for get togethers and they are always gone in exaggeration...they are great!

  5. Fort Wayne Coney Island mix !

    Posted by on 3rd Sep 2016

    Was super excited to try this !! I was a chef at the summit club next door for eleven years and had Coney Island 4-5 times a week ! I have lived in California now for almost 7 years without a coney in sight ! Needless to say it just doesn't even come close to the original sauce from Fort Wayne ! They are definitly leaving something out

  6. Still Testing, but...

    Posted by Ken on 22nd Mar 2016

    Tasty, but will use much less spice than specified in the recipe next time.

  7. I like this

    Posted by Gaylord on 6th Oct 2015

    This product is very nice, not sure it matches the original but it can stand on its own as a product worth having. I have a lot of things I want to try it with.


    Posted by Unknown on 29th Jan 2013

    I use it in anything that calls for chili powder and other spices. I used it in my meatloaf, it gave it a good flavor. Will buy it again.

  9. Just like the Fort Wayne Hot Dogs I lve.

    Posted by Sharon on 19th Jul 2011

    I love this seasoning! I can make the Coney Dogs from Fort Wayne,IN I grow up on at home. With the seasoning you can add as much or as little fat as you want. What I do is add more seasoning and water and leaner hamburger if I want to make it healthier. If that isn't important to you, follow the directions add a little more seasoning and if you would like you can add extra fat like crisco to it. I will tell you, the longer it sits the more the flavors of the spice go through the mix. I simmer for 3 hours